Top 8 Products for Scar Removal

Injuries are an unavoidable part of living, so almost everyone ends up with a scar or two during their lifetime. You might not be bothered by your scars and even wear them as a badge of pride. Conversely, you might prefer it if you could at least lessen their appearance or fade them altogether. If you fall into the latter camp, put down the phone and save that appointment with the dermatologist for later—you might be able to fade your scars using dermatologist-approved scar removal products instead. 

This article reveals the top 8 products for scar removal currently available, so keep reading for beautiful skin.

Comparison Table

Brand Size Ingredients
Mederma Advanced Scar Gel 1.76 oz Allantoin, onion extract
Derma-E Scar Gel 2 oz Allicin, Allantoin, Vitamin B5
Bio-Oil Skin Care Oil 6.7 oz Chamomile, Purcellin oil
ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets 4 counts Silicone
Kelo-Cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel .35 oz Silicone, Polysiloxanes
Cica-Care Gel Sheet 1 count Silicone
Mederma for Kids .70 oz Allantoin, onion extract
HoneyDew Concealing Cream 4fl oz Vitamin E, rosehip, avocado oil

The Top 8 Products for Scar Removal in 2022

Now that we’ve glanced at how these products compare, let’s look at each one in more detail.

1. Mederma Advanced Scar Gel – Best Overall

Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is an all-rounder when it comes to fading scars. A 1.76-ounce bottle of this scar removal product helps fade cuts, scars, bruises, and acne scars, among many others. Additionally, the product lessens the appearance of old scars, and it works great even if you have sensitive skin.

Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is formulated with ingredients like onion extract and Allantoin. The former ingredient has anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties, while the latter helps with irritation, itchiness, and dryness.

The only drawback to this gel is that it lacks sunscreen, which is necessary because exposure to the sun darkens the appearance of scars. However, using the gel shouldn’t be an issue if you avoid being in the sun for too long.


  • Works for a wide range of scars
  • Okay for use on sensitive skin
  • Contains natural ingredients with anti-inflammatory properties
  • Can lighten the appearance of old scars


  • Doesn’t contain sunscreen

Bottom Line

You’ll appreciate the Mederma Advanced Scar Gel if you have sensitive skin or are trying to lighten the appearance of an old scar. This scar gel is also great if you’re trying to fade different kinds of scars simultaneously.

2. Derma-E Scar Gel – Runner Up

Derma-E Scar Gel is a fantastic scar removal product formulated with all-natural ingredients. This scar gel contains Allicin, an onion bulb extract that’s great for reducing the appearance of scars, and Vitamin B5, a moisturizing ingredient that provides smooth skin. Additionally, it contains Allantoin, a skin conditioner. All-in-all, you can fade scars while rejuvenating your skin.

Each 2-ounce bottle of Derma-E helps to reduce the appearance of superficial scars, including sunburn and stretch marks. If you love animals, you’ll appreciate that Derma-E is produced cruelty-free. Also, this gel isn’t too greasy, so you won’t have to worry about it staining your clothes. 

You’ll have to apply it 2-3 times daily for at least eight weeks when treating new scars for best results. Unfortunately, you’ll have to use the gel twice daily for at least six months to see any noticeable improvements in the appearance of older scars.


  • Contains Vitamin B5, which moisturizes skin
  • Great for sunburns and stretch marks
  • Cruelty-free


  • Takes a minimum of six months to lessen the appearance of older scars

Bottom Line

If cruelty-free production is non-negotiable for you when choosing beauty products, Derma-E Scar Gel is the perfect scar removal product for your needs. Its all-natural ingredients may also be appealing to you if you want a product that helps your skin while fading scars.

3. Bio-Oil Skincare Oil – Best for Stretch Marks

Bio-Oil Skincare Oil is a multi-purpose skincare product that pulls double-duty as a scar removal formula. It shines when reducing the appearance of stretch marks, making it ideal for women post-pregnancy and people who’ve lost drastic amounts of weight.

In addition to lightening acne scars, hand scars, and stretch marks, you can use it for your hair, face, and body.

This oil is formulated with chamomile and Purcellin oil and contains Vitamins A and E, two vitamins that hydrate skin and promote collagen. Moreover, it contains calendula, an ingredient with antibacterial properties, so it’s great for use on fresh scars.

However, heads up if you’re used to using more viscous skincare products–Bio-oil can feel a little slippery and isn’t absorbed by the skin as quickly.


  • Contains the calming ingredient chamomile
  • All-purpose skincare product
  • Fantastic for stretch marks


  • Oil may be too slick for some

Bottom Line

Get Bio-Oil Skincare Oil if you’d like to fade stretch marks. It’s also great as a general-purpose beauty product and can be used on the hair, face, and body.

4. ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets – Best for Surgical Scars

ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets differ from the other products on our list in that they forgo cream, gel, and oil formulations for a silicone sheet. However, that’s not to say these scar sheets are less effective. On the contrary, ScarAway is great for surgical scars like C-Sections.

These breathable sheets work by hydrating and softening the scar while protecting it from the elements. Moreover, the sheets can be worn for twenty-four hours and are reusable. The adhesive mimics the natural skin barrier for optimal healing of fresh scars. It can be irritating for some but, on the whole, does its job. 

You get twelve sheets in every pack of ScarAway. If you have a fresh scar, you may notice improvements in its appearance within weeks. However, expect results to take a while when using the scar sheets on an older scar.


  • Great for surgical scars
  • You can wear the sheets for twenty-four hours
  • Protect scars from the elements


  • The sheet’s adhesive may irritate your skin

Bottom Line

You’ll appreciate the ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets if you’re trying to fade a surgical scar like a Cesarean. Additionally, if your scar is fresh, you’ll love these sheets since they protect it from the elements while fading it.

5. Kelo-Cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel – Best Silicone-Based Alternative 

If you’re intrigued by silicone scar sheets but aren’t ready to take the plunge, the Kelo-Cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel is an excellent alternative. This self-drying gel is similarly suitable for surgical scars and is also silicone-based. Moreover, you can use it to minimize scarring as soon as a wound has been closed.

Kelo-Cote reduces scars resulting from burns, surgery, insect bites, scrapes and scratches, and acne. It’s also excellent for hypertrophic and keloid scars and can be worn under makeup.

Additionally, you can use it on fresh and old scars, with its moisturizing properties helping to reduce collagen build-up in fresh ones.

To see any results, you’ll have to use this scar removal gel for at least 90 days. The only downside to this product is that its two main ingredients (silicone and Polysiloxanes) aren’t organic.


  • Suitable for use on hypertrophic and keloid scars
  • Can be used on fresh and old scars
  • You can use it to minimize scarring as soon as the wound is closed


  • Not made with all-natural ingredients

Bottom Line

Kelo-Cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel will be perfect if you’re interested in silicone-based scar treatment. In addition, it’s an excellent choice for minimizing hypertrophic or keloid scars, so you’ll want to purchase this one if your type of scar falls into either category.

6. Cica-Care Gel Sheet – Most Reusable

The Cica-Care Gel Sheet is an excellent choice if you’re on a budget, and all kudos go to its incredibly reusable sheets. Not only are the sheets washable, but you can also customize them by cutting them to fit the shape and size of your scar.

Additionally, these gel sheets are effective when it comes to minimizing scars. They can smoothen and soften the appearance and improve texture and color. You might even forget you have them on due to how comfortable it is to wear the gel sheets.

However, if there’s one place where these sheets fall short, it’s their grip. While functional most of the time, the sheets are prone to coming loose when used on parts of your body that you move a lot (e.g., your knees). Otherwise, it’s hard to pass up these gel sheets.


  • Very reusable sheets
  • Can be cut to the size and shape of your scar
  • Extremely comfortable


  • The sheet may come loose when used on parts of the body you move a lot

Bottom Line

You won’t want to pass up on the Cica-Care Gel Sheet if you’re on a budget. This product’s high reuse factor and customizability make it highly appealing, and it gets the job done.

7. Mederma for Kids – Best for Children

Most people probably pick up most of their scars during their childhood, and it’ll probably be no different for their kids. Therefore, Mederma for Kids is the perfect scar removal product to keep on hand if you have physically active kids.

Mederma for Kids helps accelerate collagen production while hydrating and moisturizing scars. Your kids will love the purple color of the cream, and its smell isn’t so overpowering as to take the fun out of the healing process.

Your kids will need to use this product for a minimum of eight weeks to see noticeable improvements for new scars. Meanwhile, older ones require at least three to six months of use. However, we must warn that this scar removal product should only be used on closed wounds, so please refrain from using it on broken skin.


  • Suitable for kids
  • Doesn’t have a strong smell
  • The cream has a fun kid-friendly purple color


  • You can’t use it on open wounds

Bottom Line

If you’re a parent to rambunctious kids, you’ll want to keep Mederma for Kids close. Your kids will love rubbing on this purple scar cream, and it doesn’t have a harsh smell that screams “Treatment.” Moreover, seeing undeniable results in eight weeks is a plus.

8. HoneyDew Concealing Cream – Best for Face Scars

Vitamin E, avocado oil, and rosehip are three of many natural ingredients used to formulate HoneyDew Concealing Cream. Completely paraben-free, this scar removal cream is excellent for fading scars on the face, thanks to its hydrating formula that doesn’t clog pores.

Using HoneyDew Concealing Cream, you can lighten old and new scars and moisturize your skin while doing so. It also helps to lessen the appearance of stretch marks and has no scent.

Unfortunately, this cream requires dedicated use because you won’t see results until after months of use. 


  • Paraben-free
  • Perfect for face scars (won’t clog pores)
  • Moisturizes skin


  • Takes a while to see significant improvements

Bottom Line

If you’re trying to lessen the appearance of a facial scar (acne perhaps), get HoneyDew Concealing Cream. Its hydrating formula means you won’t have to worry about getting your pores clogged when using it on your face. Also, it’s formulated with all-natural ingredients.

Factors to Consider When Buying Products for Scar Removal 

Below are some of the main factors to consider when purchasing a scar removal product:


While not every scar removal product may use all-natural, organic products in their formula, it’s best to prioritize the ones that do. Some formulations that use harsh chemicals may irritate the skin. Additionally, you’ll want to check the ingredient list if the formula uses something you’re allergic to.

Scar Type

You’ll need to consider the type of scar you’re trying to fade when picking a scar removal product. Some products are excellent for use on surgical scars, while others help fade the appearance of hypertrophic scars. Therefore, if you’re trying to fade a hypertrophic scar, a scar cream for stretch marks may not give you the results you’re looking for.

Sun Protection

Exposure to the sun is the quickest way to darken scars. You might not have this problem if you’re completely covered up while outside or if you have an indoor lifestyle. However, if you’re always outdoors, pick a scar removal product with sunscreen.

Cream, Gel, Oil, or Sheet

Whether you prefer using a cream, gel, oil, or sheet, you’ll find a scar removal product that suits your needs. However, each one comes with pros and cons. On the one hand, while some gels and oils may be fast-absorbing, you might not like how slippery they feel against your skin. 

On the other hand, sheets may be less greasy to the touch, but the adhesive might irritate sensitive skin.

Dubious Claims

Scar removal products don’t work miracles, nor will they work on every type of scar. Additionally, most scar products take time to work, so any marketing that promises unbelievably fast improvements should be taken with a pinch of salt. Therefore, be wary of hyperbole marketing and dubious claims.


It isn’t always true that an expensive product means it’s the most effective. Therefore, your budget should play a part in the product you purchase. For example, you can use multi-purpose scar removal products like Bio-Oil for scar removal and general body care.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do Scar Removal Products Actually Work?

Yes, they do. However, their effectiveness depends on the type of scars they’re being used to fade. Very deep or severe scars may require medical treatment like laser therapy or cryosurgery before they can fade.

How Do Scar Removal Products Work?

Scar removal products work based on the ingredients used to formulate them. While some work as an exfoliant and scrub away dead skin cells to lessen the scar’s appearance, other products may reduce the appearance of scarring by hydrating the skin.

How Long Does It Take for Scar Removal Products to Work?

It depends on the type of scar being treated. Some products may take a couple of months to work before you see any significant improvement in the appearance of the scar. However, if your scar requires medical treatment, you’d be better off seeing a dermatologist than using a scar removal product.

Final Thoughts

With any of our top 8 products for scar removal, you should be able to minimize the appearance of your scars, whether new or old, within a few months. Undoubtedly, our number one recommendation is Mederma Advanced Scar Gel, due to how useful it is for numerous kinds of scars. It’s also full of natural ingredients, which we welcome. If you’re also considering a pain relief gel, here is one we recommend. 

Derma-E Scar Gel comes in at a close second as a great alternative to Mederma’s product. It also scores points for being produced cruelty-free. Finally, you can opt for Bio-Oil Skincare Oil if you’re looking for a scar removal product that can also be used for general body care.

Related Articles 

Trust Guard Security Scanned